Disclaimer: I provide web development software services and am involved with several of the “big names” mentioned in this November 2009 USA TODAY article “Could this finally be the season for Web TV? “ [1]. In fact, I am working with two of the organizations and am bound by non-disclosure agreements which obligate me to not disclose their names or what work we are doing together which may enable METROmilwaukee (sm) to release software services the general public may use to send digital media to HDTV sets like we do using our computers and other digital devices; digital signs, desktops, servers, notebooks, netbooks or mobile phones: any and all digital devices with some type of display (television screen).
That said, when USA TODAY asks “Could this finally be the season for Web TV?” the answer is a resounding “yes, but…” to discuss and answer that question honestly also requires some “Howevers” and “Furthermores” because the status quo propaganda from USA TODAY and others of that ilk do not disclose any of the the whys, whats and wherefores as they pertain to the self interest of the consumer; people like you and I that actually purchase and own HDTVs presumably as our private property.
USA TODAY and the many others writing about this timely topic of web-enabled HDTV are quite exciting and seemingly believable at face value -–however— informed consumers who really understand and demand value when spending their money will read between the lines and continue to heed my advise:
This –-period of transition-- is the worst time in history to buy a new HDTV because the HDTV manufacturers are selling crippleware: HDTV sets that are intentionally crippled down to hinder or otherwise prevent using a web browser to send and receive from the WWW.
The USA TODAY article repeats the allegation put forth by HDTV marketers “we (TV manufacturers) do not want to allow a browser to be used on the TV because our research indicates customers do not want to use their TV to access the web the same way they can when using any other way to do so.”
Your research? WTF? Their allegation is a fallacy being only partly true because there have to be some consumers that do not want anything to do with the WWW but the larger number of the rest of humanity is not quite that disconnected.
I contend the larger part of our society are able to understand the facts as they are. At this point in time when consumer electronic products are “digital” there is not a wit of difference between an HDTV and any other contemporary digital device with a screen but for one distinguishing feature: a “tuner” which enables the owner (operator) of the HDTV to select a “channel” representing what an over-the-air broadcaster exclusively controlled what was and what was not displayed on the screen. Even cable operators use some forms of over-the-air but in general they are also now our Internet Service Provider that allows us to use the WWW. Can they to be involved in what is a conspiracy to deprive you and I the full use and enjoyment of our own private property? Well, yes, but only if we decide to purchase it that way from them.
When TV was first invented the tuner was an electro-mechanical device. Now tuners are digital. In fact “tuners” are not even really needed anymore. Instead of over-the-air broadcasting and doing it the way it used to be done anybody can now presumably broadcast digitally using the WWW using the HyperText Transfer Protocol. In fact tens of millions of us do broadcast digitally every day and every night in every nation on this entire planet. I am still compelled to say presumably because it seems to be an apparent fact that the over-the-air broadcasters and the HDTV manufacturers and their collaborators do not want your or I to use our HDTV sets that way.
They claim “the customer wants us to keep things simple.” Well, wasn’t Web TV ® simple enough? Hell yes. We owned Web TV in our household. The original Web TV was simple, so simple my mother and other older grandmas were using Web TV because it was so simple. But that kind of “simple” actually failed because Web TV could not be used to allow people to access the WWW to view the web pages and other types of digital media the way the customer may have actually needed or wanted.
That type of simple failed for two reasons:
- The TV screens could not display higher resolutions (loosely defined as “readability”) and the Web TV hardware could not be used to change the resolution of the TV screen so an entire web page could be displayed; we could not zoom into portions of the page and attempts to scroll were so terrible nobody cared to do so.
- The Web TV hardware required web pages to use a required type of web page template (formatting) so owners of Web TV could not view an entire web page published to the WWW unless the web page(s) used the page formatting template imposed by the Web TV hardware.
In other words, that kind of simple failed because the Web TV hardware was intentionally crippled to prevent the use of a web browser to view the many types of web pages that have been created and the same damn reasons are currently being forced upon us by the HDTV manufacturers who are intentionally crippling the HDTV to prevent the use of the browser all over again.
Yes folks, the over-the-air broadcasters are in collusion with the HDTV manufacturers to manipulate “simplicity” to try to achieve the same goal they happened to fail at the last time: complete control of your private property you bought and paid for so they and only they can determine exclusively what can and what can not be displayed on your HDTV set, who pays the money (you and I) and who gets the money (them and only them).
Deciphered: the over-the-air broadcasters, the HDTV manufacturer’s and their collaborators marketing propaganda really means:
- We know TV has become a marketplace that generates tens of billions of dollars every year that we and we alone have exclusively controlled and if unopposed we intend to continue to do so (sniff).
- Because the WWW is a free market we now realize we cannot continue to exclusively control all of that money so we are going to try to sell crippled HDTV sets and we really don’t give a damn if we cause even more jobs to be lost or prevent any new forms of business to emerge as long as we and we alone control the billions of dollars we take out of the pockets of advertisers and consumers (sniff-sniff).
- We realize if we do not cripple HDTV and prevent the emergence of new business and new jobs in America we will lose our ability to exclusively control 100% –everything-- that is or is not allowed to be displayed on an HDTV screen a browser could be used with the WWW!
OMG “What are we going to do?” they ask themselves.
So the HDTV manufacturers are going to try to do everything they can do as long as they can to keep the consumer ignorant and locked in by attempting to sell crippled HDTV that cannot be used to fully send and receive to and from the WWW.
BUT ONLY AS LONG AS YOU KEEP GIVING THEM YOUR MONEY FOR CRIPPLED HDTV PRODUCTS!
The strategy of attempting to sell proprietary crippled products has not worked for desktop computers, mobile computers, phones or any other type of digital device that connects to the WWW has it? They tried in the beginning and every one of them failed and many of the companies no longer even exist. Is this not the reality you have observed over the past decade? Is this not the truth as you yourself have experienced it?
Well, the same facts and truths will become true of the HDTV but:
IF AND ONLY IF WE DO NOT FUND THE HDTV MANUFACTURERES BY PURCHASING CRIPPLED HDTV SETS.
Pandora’s box has been opened. Sure, for the time-being plenty of ignorant consumers are going to keep showing up at WalMart, Target and Best Buy to waste their money on crippled HDTV products simply because TV HAS BECOME A MEANS TO CONTROL WHAT PEOPLE ARE LED TO BELIEVE KEEPING THEM IGNORANT WHILE THE WWW HAS BECOME THE MEANS TO EDUCATE PEOPLE AND BECOME INFORMED.
The informed consumer will be patient and let the market competition that is already occurring compel HDTV manufacturers to sell products which provide real value: HDTV that supports web browsers that allow each of us to send or receive to the WWW anytime we want, to whatever source of content on the web we want, unhindered and without obstruction. I do not need the over-the-air broadcasting networks or any HDTV manufacturer to dictate how I can or cannot use my own private property with the WWW. Do you?
[1] http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/techinnovations/2009-11-13-1Awebtv13_CV_N.htm